Ensuring no duplicate term descriptions: problem
The mysql data type text cannot be a full unique index. At best a portion (prefix) of it can be indexed. If made a unique index, two entries which start the same for the length of the prefix but have different endings it will cause an incorrect duplicate key error. Which is inconvenient.
Here's the bad news on mysql unique key on longtext:
http://casey.shobe.info/mysql_limitations.html#Text_columns_cannot_be_unique
Here's the official bad news:
http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.1/en/blob.html
Searching for a workaround didn't work:
ensuring unique blob text using hash
mysql unique text
using a hash to ensure unique text mysql
OK, so another tact...
drupal storing diffs
drupal storing revisions as diffs
I found and posted at DWW's old question "Managing node revisions with a backend like subversion?" (which came up again in this large recent thread on requiring node revisions or not).
I do think revision control should be pursued, or else we should work on a Drupal way (modeled on Mercurial/Git?) of saving revisions as diffs. Even for a little piece of my Community Managed Taxonomy module which allows people to vote on term descriptions, I would have loved versions saved as diffs. This would build in ensuring uniqueness at the same time it saves space and stores, by definition, information about what changed..
Of course, the whole subject of being able to vote on changes to a text could be ten research papers across five disciplines.
I'm not sure what the practical solution to ensuring we don't have duplicate descriptions (which would cause vote counts to be incorrectly separated).
The mysql data type text cannot be a full unique index. At best a portion (prefix) of it can be indexed. If made a unique index, two entries which start the same for the length of the prefix but have different endings it will cause an incorrect duplicate key error. Which is inconvenient.
Here's the bad news on mysql unique key on longtext:
http://casey.shobe.info/mysql_limitations.html#Text_columns_cannot_be_unique
Here's the official bad news:
http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.1/en/blob.html
Searching for a workaround didn't work:
ensuring unique blob text using hash
mysql unique text
using a hash to ensure unique text mysql
OK, so another tact...
drupal storing diffs
drupal storing revisions as diffs
I found and posted at DWW's old question "Managing node revisions with a backend like subversion?" (which came up again in this large recent thread on requiring node revisions or not).
I do think revision control should be pursued, or else we should work on a Drupal way (modeled on Mercurial/Git?) of saving revisions as diffs. Even for a little piece of my Community Managed Taxonomy module which allows people to vote on term descriptions, I would have loved versions saved as diffs. This would build in ensuring uniqueness at the same time it saves space and stores, by definition, information about what changed..
Of course, the whole subject of being able to vote on changes to a text could be ten research papers across five disciplines.
I'm not sure what the practical solution to ensuring we don't have duplicate descriptions (which would cause vote counts to be incorrectly separated).
Comments
Post new comment